Bay Colony
Stuart, Florida · Martin County · Single-family homes
Typical Prices: $1,125,000–$1,600,000
About Bay Colony
Stuart · Martin County, Florida
Bay Colony is an established residential neighborhood in Stuart, Martin County, Florida. County records show roughly 40 homesites, with homes built 1979–2023 and a median living area of about 3,451 sq ft.
Bay Colony is a non-gated single-family home community in Stuart with homes built between 1979 and 2023 and a median living area of about 3,135 square feet on lots with a median size of 0.49 acres. Most listings are waterfront, with features recorded including ocean access, river frontage, navigable water, seawalls and no fixed bridges. HOA fees are billed monthly, typically ranging from $67 to $117 with a median of $75, covering common areas; assigned schools are Felix A. Williams Elementary, Stuart Middle and Jensen Beach High. The listings below come from the MLS subdivision records for Bay Colony, so you only see homes actually inside the community.
Location context: Martin County is served by I-95, US-1, and the Florida Turnpike. Stuart to West Palm Beach runs ~40 min; to Fort Lauderdale ~70 min; to Port St. Lucie ~20 min. The county's low-density character and Intracoastal access attract buyers seeking a quieter Treasure Coast alternative to Palm Beach County.
Search Only Inside Bay Colony
Most Stuart searches return everything in the zip code. The listings on this page are matched by MLS subdivision name, and this map search uses the neighborhood's recorded plat boundary — either way you only see homes for sale that are actually inside Bay Colony.
Open the Neighborhood Map SearchRefine by price, beds, and baths on the map, or save the search to be alerted the moment a new listing appears inside the boundary.
Neighborhood Snapshot
Bay Colony — Stuart, Martin County (Martin County Property Appraiser data)
- Zoned schools: Felix A. Williams, Stuart, Jensen Beach
- Homes built 1979–2023
- About 40 homesites
Why Choose Bay Colony?
Key reasons buyers and sellers choose this Martin County community
Established Stuart Location
Bay Colony sits in Stuart, within easy reach of Stuart / Treasure Coast employment, the beaches, and the Intracoastal. Martin County is served by I-95, US-1, and the Florida Turnpike.
Know the Real Value Before You Offer
Resale pricing in Bay Colony swings with condition, updates, roof and A/C age, and insurance costs. Our team runs neighborhood comps and checks the details that move value before you commit.
Sell With a Neighborhood Expert
If you own in Bay Colony, we track every sale inside the boundary, price your home against true in-neighborhood comps, and market it to buyers already searching this community.
Major Employers Within Commuting Distance
Key employment centers accessible from Stuart / Treasure Coast
Places of Interest
Water
- Sandsprit Park boat ramp~10 min
- Manatee Pocket (Port Salerno)~15 min
- St. Lucie Inlet~20 min
Beaches
- Stuart Beach~15 min
- Bathtub Reef Beach~20 min
- Jensen Beach~20 min
Healthcare
- Cleveland Clinic Martin North~10 min
- Cleveland Clinic Martin South~10 min
- Tradition Medical Center~25 min
Shopping
- Downtown Stuart~10 min
- Treasure Coast Square~10 min
- Publix / Kanner Hwy shops~5 min
Bay Colony at a Glance
Home types: single-family homes
MLS subdivision names: Bay Colony, Bay Colony Of Stuart, Bay Colony Of Stuart & First Addition, Bay Colony Of Stuart Jensen Beach
Active listing prices: $1.65M (active listing)
Recent sales: $1.50M–$1.50M (1 closed sales, last 12 months)
HOA: $67–$117/month
Also searched as: Bay Colony Stuart FL, Bay Colony waterfront homes Stuart, ocean access homes Stuart FL, river front homes Martin County, Bay Colony HOA fees, single family homes Stuart Florida, no fixed bridges homes Stuart, Jensen Beach High School zoned homes
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about Bay Colony and buying or selling in Martin County
Explore Similar Communities
Other Martin County communities worth comparing
Park Place
Another Martin County community worth comparing — boundary-based listings, values, and local insight.
View Community ›Bay Shore Village
Another Martin County community worth comparing — boundary-based listings, values, and local insight.
View Community ›Country Club Cove
Another Martin County community worth comparing — boundary-based listings, values, and local insight.
View Community ›Why Work With Paradise Realty FLA?
A Stuart-based brokerage serving Martin, Palm Beach, St. Lucie, and Indian River counties — direct representation, in-neighborhood comps, financing review, and transaction coordination through closing.
Never Miss an Opportunity
We offer a saved-search process that can track new listings, price changes, and back-on-market homes inside Bay Colony and send you alerts — so you have the chance to act on opportunities before they are gone.
Never Pay Too Much
A list price is not a value. We offer a comparable market analysis (CMA) using closed sales inside Bay Colony before you write an offer — just ask, and we will prepare it — so you can base your offer on what the home is worth, not what it is listed for.
Intake + Coordination
Dually licensed intake consultation, direct Realtor representation, and a transaction coordinator through closing.
Contract Guidance
Navigate inspections, insurance, financing contingencies, and negotiation with an advocate who knows Martin County resale terms.
Educational First
No pressure — we serve as your educational resource every step of the way.
Deadline Protection
Transaction coordinator monitors every contract deadline and contingency from acceptance to closing.
Buyers and Sellers
Whether you are buying into Bay Colony or selling your home there, the same local expertise works for you.
Ready to Explore Bay Colony?
Talk with Paradise Realty FLA — we represent buyers and sellers in Bay Colony directly.
No current listings, please check back later.