Key Colony Beach Real Estate

Key Colony Beach Real Estate

Welcome to Key Colony Beach, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Florida Keys, within Monroe County. This enchanting city is a paradise for those seeking a tranquil lifestyle amidst stunning natural beauty and vibrant marine life. With its pristine beaches, swaying palm trees, and crystal-clear waters, Key Colony Beach offers the perfect backdrop for a relaxed, coastal living experience.

The city is renowned for its friendly community and laid-back atmosphere, making it an ideal destination for families, retirees, and anyone looking to escape the hustle and bustle of daily life. Key Colony Beach is also a haven for outdoor enthusiasts, offering a plethora of activities such as fishing, kayaking, and snorkeling. The nearby waters are teeming with colorful fish and coral reefs, providing an unforgettable experience for divers and ocean lovers alike.

As a small, tight-knit community, Key Colony Beach boasts an array of charming homes, from cozy beachfront cottages to luxurious waterfront estates. Residents enjoy access to local amenities, including parks, golf courses, and delightful dining options that showcase the freshest seafood the region has to offer.

With its stunning sunsets and friendly atmosphere, Key Colony Beach is more than just a location; it’s a lifestyle. Whether you’re looking to buy your dream home or simply explore this captivating city, Key Colony Beach promises an idyllic escape where every day feels like a vacation. Come experience the magic of this coastal paradise and discover why so many choose to call Key Colony Beach home!

Newest Listings in Key Colony Beach

133 8TH Street, Key Colony Beach
$849,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B26086843 MLS
Escape to the Florida Keys with this move-in ready 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom waterfront home in Key Colony Beach! Tie up your boat just outside your back door on a navigable canal situated only 10 minutes from Key Vaca Cut channel, offering effortless access to the Atlantic Ocean, Florida Bay, sandbars, snorkeling, and world-class fishing. Key improvements include modern kitchen and bathrooms, fresh exterior paint, impact-rated hurricane windows and doors (excluding glass block), replaced patio decking, renovated wood dock complete with electric, water and a fish cleaning station. Offered fully furnished, it is completely equipped for personal enjoyment or immediate 7-day vacation rental management. Inside, the home is tailored for effortless coastal living. The separate living room is situated just off the combination kitchen and dining area, offering plenty of space for entertaining family or watching the big game with friends. Modern indoor features include four TVs, a dedicated beverage/beer froster to keep drinks ice-cold, an attached carport, generous storage, and a separate laundry/storage room. Step outside to connect with the island's community bike paths—which run throughout Key Colony and are wonderful for walking or cycling directly to Sunset Park to catch a stunning Keys sunset. Key Colony Beach offers a premier, walk-friendly community lifestyle with exceptional amenities just down the street: a 9-hole Par-3 golf course, pickleball courts, basketball, a dog park, a children's playground, and games for everyone to enjoy. Conveniently walk or drive to popular local dining spots including waterfront favorite Havana Jack's for live music, dining and cocktails. Optional memberships are available for the nearby Cabana Club, alongside an optional HOA for seasonal community events.

133 8TH Street, Key Colony Beach
51 Coral Lane, Key Colony Beach
$799,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B26079651 MLS
Enjoy waterfront living in Key Colony Beach at a fantastic price! This inviting 3-bedroom, 3-bath stilted, CBS home, built in 2005, offers 1,428 square feet of living space and everything you need to enjoy the Florida Keys lifestyle. This waterfront home offers quick, direct access to fantastic fishing and boating, allowing you to be out on the water in no time. This home is perfect for jet skis, launching kayaks and even small skiffs. Take in beautiful canal views from either of the home's two balconies--perfect for enjoying your morning coffee or relaxing after a day on the water. Covered parking with 4 total parking spaces provide plenty of room for guests. Enjoy all that Key Colony has to offer! Call today!

51 Coral Lane, Key Colony Beach
160 10th Street, Key Colony Beach
$950,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ A12063553 MLS
Waterfront retreat in Key Colony Beach with direct ocean access and no fixed bridges. Featuring a private dock, boat lift, and jacuzzi, this home is perfect for boating, fishing, and embracing the Florida Keys lifestyle. Bright, inviting interior with seamless indoor-outdoor living, just minutes from beaches, waterfront dining, golf, and local attractions. Ideal as a primary home, vacation getaway, or investment opportunity.

160 10th Street, Key Colony Beach
46 Sadowski Causeway, Key Colony Beach
$889,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ A12056491 MLS
2BD/2BA waterfront half-duplex in Key Colony Beach, offering impressive water views from both the front and back of the home. Stilted concrete construction, metal roof and impact windows make the insurances extremely affordable. Wake up to glowing sunrises over the water and wind down with color-soaked Keys sunsets from your private balconies perfect for morning coffee, sunset cocktails, and effortless indoor-outdoor living. A deep-water pier-style dock accommodates boats up to 40 ft giving you instant access to world-class fishing, diving, and boating. Designed for adventure and convenience, the property includes parking for up to 3 vehicles, 2 covered spaces beneath the home and an additional uncovered driveway space ideal for extra parking or a boat trailer. A dedicated tackle room keeps gear organized and ready for your next trip offshore. Everything you love about Key Colony Beach is within easy walking distance, Sunset Park for oceanfront strolls and nightly sunsets, the Key Colony Beach Golf Course, tennis and pickleball courts, the Cabana Club with oceanfront pool and beach access (membership-based), and the Key Colony Beach Marina. Restaurants, walking paths, and the island's friendly, laid-back atmosphere are all right at your doorstep. With 7-day rentals permitted, this property offers excellent vacation-rental potential in one of the most desirable waterfront, boating communities in the Middle Keys. A bright, breezy coastal escape and always a pleasure to show.

46 Sadowski Causeway, Key Colony Beach
410 10th Street, Key Colony Beach
$899,995
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ A11959094 MLS
Turnkey, fully furnished waterfront property with strong Airbnb income history. Enjoy 37.5 ft of dockage with unrestricted ocean access and a quick 5-minute ride to the Gulf and ocean side. Home sits above flood, helping reduce insurance and overhead. Features include a 2017 roof and a new water heater (2025). A rare opportunity for investors or buyers seeking effortless coastal living.

410 10th Street, Key Colony Beach
Niles Road, Key Colony Beach
$750,000
A11925960 MLS
Prime residential lot opportunity in Key Colony Beach, Monroe County, located at 0 Niles Rd, Key Colony, FL 33042. This approximately 9.2-acre property is situated in the Florida Keys with convenient access to nearby points of interest including Murray's Market (0.45 miles), Big Pine Key Boat Rentals (0.6 miles), Merrill Homes Inc (0.6 miles), and WWUS-FM Big Pine Key (1.85 miles). The lot is located in Flood Zone AE, a high-risk Special Flood Hazard Area (SFHA) with a 1/100 annual flood chance and established Base Flood Elevation (BFE), requiring the lowest floor to be elevated above BFE using flood-resistant materials, engineered foundations, mandatory flood insurance, and strict permitting with elevation certificates. Wetland impacts from Mangrove Swamp and Saltwater Marshes further restrict development, as these protected ecosystems generally require U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Section 404 permits, state environmental reviews, and mitigation; while the lot size suggests potential non-wetland pockets, overall development feasibility is low without extensive studies and approvals. Buyer must contact Monroe County Planning for an official Zoning Verification Letter to confirm allowable uses, setbacks, utility availability, and all development requirements. The property is available for a self-guided tour. Subleasing is not permitted. This lot is not available for rent or lease.

Niles Road, Key Colony Beach
151 10th Street, Key Colony Beach
$849,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ A11963904 MLS
Welcome to this 2-bedroom waterfront home in Key Colony Beach offering direct canal frontage and classic island appeal. Built in 1961 and updated, this one story half duplex blends low maintenance living with functional waterfront access.Interior highlights include tile flooring throughout, ceiling fans, window treatments, and a comfortable layout with two full bathrooms and well proportioned bedrooms across approximately 952 square feet. Home Constructed using CBS (Concrete block & Stucco) for durability.Waterfront and exterior features:• Direct canal frontage with seawall• Screened porch for outdoor dining• Approximately 4,125 sq ft lot• One car garage• Paver driveway• Off street and guest parking• Front side impact windows/ Back Accordion shutters• Monitored security• 40ft Boat Dock (Seawall has permit and is being redone in April 2026)Ideal for boating enthusiasts seeking convenient canal access in Key Colony Beach. Located in Monroe County near local dining, marinas, and island amenities, this property offers an opportunity to enjoy the Florida Keys lifestyle in a manageable waterfront setting.

151 10th Street, Key Colony Beach
34 7th Street, Key Colony Beach
$847,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B26020292 MLS ⋅ Key Colony Beach BLDG.
Welcome to your Waterfront Paradise! This beautifully remodeled 2/2 is situated on a deep-water canal, 200' wide, with direct ocean access and no fixed bridges. Step outside to your private dock, complete with a 20,000 lbs. boat lift, making it effortless to get out on the water anytime you please. Inside, the home has been fully updated with modern finishes, and a stylishly renovated interior that's move-in ready. Major upgrades, including new A/C units (2025)and 2019 roof, ensuring comfort and long-term value. Relax under the 2023-built tiki hut, perfect for entertaining or unwinding. Even better, there are no rental restrictions, making this property an excellent opportunity for investors, seasonal rentals, or full-time living. This waterfront gem checks every box!

34 7th Street, Key Colony Beach
1133 W Ocean Drive Unit 17, Key Colony Beach
$1,150,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R11156123 MLS
Exquisite high-end corner residence offering breathtaking, unobstructed views of the Atlantic Ocean and the pristine beaches of Key Colony Beach. This 2 bedroom, 2 ½ bath luxury condo is bathed in natural light, featuring expansive windows that showcase endless ocean vistas and spectacular sunrises. Thoughtfully designed with an open, airy layout, the residence blends refined elegance with coastal sophistication. Enjoy seamless indoor-outdoor living from your private corner vantage point, where the sights and sounds of the ocean create a truly serene retreat. Located in the heart of Key Colony Beach, this exceptional property offers the perfect balance of privacy, comfort, and premier island living. ACTIVE VACATION RENTAL

1133 W Ocean Drive Unit 17, Key Colony Beach
Start Your Search